The mix is composed usually of aggregate and asphalt cements. Chapter 2 design and control of bituminous mixtures using. This method also addresses the treatment of reclaimed asphalt pavement rap for mix design purposes section 7. There are two major features of the marshall method of designing mixes namely, density voids analysis and stability flow test. The superpave mix design method differs from the marshall mix design methods by using performancebased and performancerelated criteria to design the proper asphalt mix. Chapter 2 design and control of bituminous mixtures using a. Since the late 1990s, the department has established a goal of implementing a newer mix design method, referred to as superpave. The marshall method seeks to select the asphalt binder content at a desired density that satisfies minimum stability and range of flow values white, 1985 1.
There are many methods available for mix design which vary in the size of the test specimen, compaction, and other test specifications. Wsdot uses the superpave mix design method also commonly called the gyratory mix design method. Currently, the hveem method is used by several western states. From basics to advanced fundamentals of asphalt mix design by marshall method. Bituminous mix design is a delicate balancing act among the proportions of various aggregate sizes and bitumen content. Evaluation of marshall and hveem mix design procedures for. Asphalt, rutting, compaction, marshall design, air voids.
Process has been referred to as a balanced mix design approach. Exp 7 marshall method of mix design civil engineers pk. For a given aggregate gradation, the optimum bitumen content is estimated by satisfyi ng a number of mix design parameters. The purpose of this guidance note is to ensure that a standardized method is applied to the design procedure. Designmarshall method and this turkish standard 3720. This section consists of a brief history of the marshall mix design method followed by a general outline of the actual method. The bulk specific gravity of aggregates and the specific gravity of the asphalt cement are determined. Sample preparation including compaction density and. The original intent of the superpave mix design method was to subject the mix design to a series of meaningful performancerelated tests that are similar to the hveem method that uses the stabilometer and cohesiometer, or the marshall method with the stability and flow test. In this method, the resistance to plastic deformation of a compacted cylindrical specimen of bituminous mixture is. In this method load is applied to a cylindrical specimen of bituminous mix and the sample is.
Prior to superpave, marshall mix design was widely used in the united states, and is by far, the most commonly used asphalt mixture design procedure worldwide. A continuing problem in the design of bituminous pavements is the specification of the properties of the mix so that it will have sufficient stability to resist displacement under traffic. There are four important hma parameters which the owner must specify in order to ensure the proper design. This technical brief provides suggestions on conducting the evaluations. The marshall stability of the mix design is defined as a maximum load carried by a compacted specimen at a standard temperature of 60 oc. The primary features of marshall mix design are a densityvoids analysis and the stabilityflow test. There are three principal bituminous mix design methods in general use. The marshall method of mix design is intended both for laboratory design and field control of bituminous hot mix dense graded paving mixtures.
Khan conventional methods of mix design can sometimes result in materials that do not perform satisfactorily. The marshall stability and flow test provides the performance prediction measure for the marshall mix design method. The aggregate gradation should not meet the project specifications. In the marshall test method of mix design three compacted samples are prepared for each binder content. The basic concepts of the marshall mix design method were originally developed by bruce marshall of the mississippi highway department around 1939 and then refined by the u. Astm d1559 has standardized the marshall test procedures. The 7 th edition of ms2 asphalt mix design methods marks the 56 th year of continuous publication of an asphalt institute mix design manual. The manual is a practical guide based on proven technologies, incorporating the most current information in 2014. Sheikh edrees, comparison of marshall and superpave asphalt design methods for sudan pavement mix es, international journal of scientific and technical advancements. The primary objective of bituminous mix design is to select aggregate gradation and asphalt binder content. General scope the department has established procedures for the design and control of bituminous concrete based on marshall method for more than 30 years. Mix design in hot mix asphalt, binder and aggregate are blended together in precise proportions. Apr 07, 2017 this lecture includes following topics what is a mix design.
Bituminous mixes are used in the surface course of road and airfield pavements. This edition offers significantly expanded application and guidance relative to our previous mix design manuals. According to astm d1559 which uses marshall mix design method for getting jmf as optimum aspahlt mix, there are 6 basic steps involved in it. Marshall method of mix design is the most popular one and is discussed. Like the hveem and marshall methods, the superpave method has been proven to produce quality hma from which longlasting pavements can be constructed. Comparison of marshall and superpave asphalt design. Superpave overview nthe final product of the shrp asphalt. Chapter 11 marshall method of asphaltconcrete mix design 11. Marshall mix design method for asphaltic concrete an arizona method 1. Chapter 11 marshall method of asphaltconcrete mix design. National pavement implementation executive task group pietg highlighted bmd as needed focus area balanced mix design task force development history shrp2 peer to peer exchange 2016. Standard test method for marshall stability and flow of. Use of marshall stability test in asphalt paving mix design c.
Stonemontqc has many features to facilitate development of asphalt mixtures including support for superpave, marshall, and hveem design methods. Maximum stability median of designed limits of percent air voids in the total mix maximum bulk specific gravity optimum bitumen content marshall stability and flow sample problem 1 the specific gravities and weight proportions for aggregate and bitumen are as under for the preparation of marshall mix design. Marshall mix design method for asphaltic concrete asphalt rubber arac an arizona method 1. In addition, marshall stability and flow can be used to monitor the plant process of producing asphalt mixture. Marshall mixes, while still available, should be replaced with the appropriate superpave speci. Superpave mix design and gyratory compaction levels. Use of marshall stability test in asphalt paving mix design. Originally developed by bruce marshall of the mississippi state highway department, the us army corps of engineers refined and added certain features to marshall s. Sep 29, 2016 the main objective of the job mix formula, mix design method, marshall mix design method is to determine an ideal and optimum asphalt mix that has following properties. These parameters include the type of asphalt binder which, in all but the most unusual circumstances, should be pg 6422 or pg64e22. Fillers desirable properties of a bituminous mixture stability, flexibility, deformation, cracking, durability, air voids, skid. Concrete mix design procedure and example is456 concrete mix design is the process of finding the proportions of concrete mix in terms of ratios of cement, sand and coarse aggregates. The main idea of the marshall mix design method involves the selection of the asphalt binder content with a suitable density which satisfies minimum stability and range of flow values.
Marshall mix design developed by bruce marshall for the mississippi highway department in the late 1930s no. Asphaltic concrete mix design apwa type 401 objective perform a marshall mix design per the asphalt institute ms2 manual and aashto test methods conforming to the kansas city metropolitan chapter of the american public works association, 2001 edition, apwa type 401 specification 50 compaction blows per face. Because the mix design procedure currently used in saudi arabiathe marshall mix designdoes not measure shear strength of the paving mixture, an attempt was made to ex plore and evaluate other design procedures, such as the hveem mix design method, and to compare their abilities to predict. Sheikh edrees, comparison of marshall and superpave asphalt design methods for sudan pavement mixes, international journal of scientific and technical. Pdf comparison of marshall and superpave asphalt design. What is marshall mix design for bituminous materials. The mix design wetmix determines the optimum bitumen content. Bituminous mix design by marshall method theory and scope. Comparison of marshall and superpave gyratory volumetric. The superpave mix design maintained the basic volumetric properties used in the marshall design. Nov 12, 2014 marshall mix design the basic concepts of the marshall mix design method were originally developed by bruce marshall of the mississippi highway department around 1939 and then refined by the us army. This lecture includes following topics what is a mix design.
All the compacted specimens are subject to the following tests. Introduction qatar began designing asphalt pavement mixes with the marshall design method in the early 1990s. This test method does not purport to address all of the safety. Pdf comparative evaluation for mix design of marshall and. Marshall mix design is the widely used method throughout india. The desirable bituminous mix properties include stability, density, durability, flexibility, resistance to skidding and workability during construction. Designing concrete mixtures there are three phases in the development of a concrete mixture. The marshall mix design method was originally developed by bruce marshall of the mississippi highway department in 1939. The design of bituminous mixture by the departments modified marshall method involves the proportioning of the aggregates and asphalt to produce a mix. The relative proportions of these materials determine the physical properties of the hma and ultimately how the hma performs as a finished pavement. Army crops of engineers, through extensive research and correlation studies, improved and added certain features to marshall s test procedure, and ultimately developed mix design criteria. Properties considered in mix design superpave mix design method. To compare between two mix design methods, marshall test was also investigated.
This is preceded by the dry mix design discussed in the previous chapter. The contractor establishes the initial parameters for a mix design and serves as the starting point for subsequent proportioning calculations. Pdf chapter 11 marshall method of asphaltconcrete mix. Marshall mix design asphalt concrete properties stability stripping workability fatigue cracking skid resistance thermal cracking durability bleeding civl. At least four binder contents are to be tested to get the optimum binder content. One of the advantages of the marshall mix design method is that the performance of the mixes can be expected for local materials and environmental impact. Originally developed by bruce marshall of the mississippi state highway department, the us army corps of engineers refined and added certain features to marshalls. There are two major features of the marshall method of designing mixes namely, density. Hma is a state of the art mix design system which replaced the old standard marshall method of mix design. This method covers the formulas used to compute the various values used in the marshall mix design of 100% virgin aggregate mixtures or reclaimed material and virgin aggregate mixtures. The main objective of the job mix formula, mix design method, marshall mix design method is to determine an ideal and optimum asphalt mix that has following properties. In addition, marshall stability and flow can be used to monitor the plant process of producing. The stability portion of the test measures the maximum load supported by the test specimen at a loading rate of 50. Superpave gyratory method washington asphalt pavement.
Aggregate mix components can be easily updated or substituted in all mixes because of the tight integration between asphalt mixes and aggregate products. Currently, the marshall method is used in some capacity by about 38 states. The most popular mix design methods done through marshall stability and flow test to provides the performance prediction the stability of the specimen measures when the maximum load occurs at a loading rate of 50. The superpave mix design system evaluates the volumetric properties of the compacted samples. Mix design method for asphalt concrete and other hot mix types mix design methods for asphalt concrete and other hot mix types, 1962 3. Bruce marshall, a former bituminous engineer with the mississippi state highway department, formulated the concepts of the marshall method of designing paving mixtures. Marshall mix design the basic concepts of the marshall mix design method were originally developed by bruce marshall of the mississippi highway department around 1939 and then refined by the us army. Properties considered in mix design superpave mix design.
They are marshall method, hveem method and superpave method. Apparatus to test maximum specific gravity as per astm d2041 etc. The mix should not distort or be displaced when subjected to traffic loads. Chapter 4 marshall mix design and analysis shodhganga. Design and optimum are often used interchangeably however, they mean two different things there can be many design binder contents for a mix, but only one truly optimum optimum indicates the best binder content based on intended application, performance requirementsneeds, and ultimately economics. An example of proportioning a mix design through use of this form is detailed in table 3. Marshall method of mix design the basic concepts of the marshall mix design method were originally developed by bruce marshall of the mississippi highway department around 1939 and then refined by the u.
Originally developed by bruce marshall of the mississippi state highway department, the us army corps of engineers refined and added certain features to marshalls approach and it was then subsequently formalized as astm d. The materials should meet the project specifications. Ppt asphalt mix design marshall method rajib chattaraj. For the typical mix design procedure, aggregate is separated into at least three stockpiles. Refinements to the concepts of asphalt mix design procedures came about not only with.
539 1133 303 1564 1567 1499 470 1196 185 1633 1411 255 172 937 73 1445 695 738 1216 993 926 1213 588 924 118 1269 498 1113 1194 216 31 142 1494